New City Council Lines Announced

map New City Council Lines AnnouncedThe Districting Commission tasked with redrawing City Council lines unveiled yesterday the latest, and likely last, version of those lines. After a process fraught with alleged backroom deals and heated public hearings, the lines are a City Council vote away from being final for another decade.

Some alterations were made to satisfy the demands of civic groups and minority advocacy organizations, but, at first glance, many were not.

Continue reading “New City Council Lines Announced”

Steve Israel: Redistricting Helped Team Blue

steve israel ny1 Steve Israel: Redistricting Helped Team Blue
Congressman Israel (Photo: NY1)

New York Congressman Steve Israel, who heads up the House Democrats’ campaign efforts, made an interesting pitch to NY1’s Errol Louis on Inside City Hall last Friday. He argued the most New York is now in play with the judge’s new congressional redistricting plan.

“Right in New York, as a result of the map the courts have approved, we have races all over the state that will be competitive,” he said, before ticking down a laundry list of newly competitive seats.

Continue reading “Steve Israel: Redistricting Helped Team Blue”

Bill Samuels: Cuomo Has Lost His Chance for Greatness, Forever

 Bill Samuels: Cuomo Has Lost His Chance for Greatness, Forever
Governor Cuomo (Photo: Wikimedia)

Earlier today, good government advocate Bill Samuels took the rhetorical hammer to Governor Andrew Cuomo’s record over his middle-of-the-night compromise legislation on redistricting reform this week.

“I think it’s a historically terrible thing for the history of our state,” he began his interview with The Capitol Pressroom‘s Susan Arbetter.

“To the extent our governor had a chance to be a great governor, when history is written, that opportunity is gone forever,” he continued. “It’s only a question of whether maybe he can go down in history maybe as a mediocre governor.”

Continue reading “Bill Samuels: Cuomo Has Lost His Chance for Greatness, Forever”

Democrats Make ‘Highly Unusual’ Request for Court to Intervene on Senate Lines

new district 34 Democrats Make Highly Unusual Request for Court to Intervene on Senate Lines
The Senate Democrats would like to see districts like this still see some change.

Earlier today, the New York State Senate Democrats asked the court currently enacting the state’s new Congressional redistricting plan to consider expanding their efforts and, at the very least, draw up their own maps for the State Senate as well.

They made two core arguments about the need for this legal action in their letter to the court.

“First, the Legislature’s plan is subject to preclearance by the Department of  Justice pursuant to section 5 of the Voting Rights Act, a process that can take up to 60 days,” the wrote, referring to the required process of federal review for some counties in New York like the Bronx, Manhattan, and Brooklyn.

Continue reading “Democrats Make ‘Highly Unusual’ Request for Court to Intervene on Senate Lines”

Grading the Redistricting Amendment

questionableart1 Grading the Redistricting AmendmentProfessor Gerry Benjamin, an expert on the mechanisms of government at State University of New York at New Paltz, was asked by Citizens’ Committee for an Effective Constitution to take a look at Governor Andrew Cuomo and the Legislature’s much-touted redistricting amendment and grade it point-by-point against what a truly independent amendment would look like.

Unsurprisingly, he found it wanting. He gave the amendment a ‘C-‘ overall on an ‘A’ through ‘F’ scale.

Continue reading “Grading the Redistricting Amendment”

And Here It Is: Cuomo Hails Redistricting Deal

new 19 And Here It Is: Cuomo Hails Redistricting Deal
The Republican Senate drew Democratic State Senate candidate Lew Fidler's house, in the southeastern part of this new district, into a fellow Democrat's seat.

In the wee hours of the morning, Governor Andrew Cuomo blasted out a statement touting two of the three aspects of his redistricting compromise: a constitutional amendment providing a commission to draw districts the in the future and a statue to implement the amendment as ordinary law if the Legislature doesn’t follow through with its promise to pass the amendment in the subsequent legislative session.

(Left unsaid are the “less hyper-political” lines standard he previously presented as a condition of his support.)

“This agreement will permanently reform the redistricting process in New York to once and for all end self-interested and partisan gerrymandering,” Governor Cuomo said in the release.

Continue reading “And Here It Is: Cuomo Hails Redistricting Deal”

Senate GOP Objection: Court Map ‘Needlessly Violates New York’s Traditional Redistricting Principles’

new district number 5 Senate GOP Objection: Court Map Needlessly Violates New York’s Traditional Redistricting PrinciplesThis afternoon, the Republicans controlling the New York State Senate filed their formal objection to the congressional redistricting plan currently being considered by a three-judge panel, and their arguments directly centered on the need for incumbency protection measures for Republican Representatives.

“Professor Persily generally dismisses the Senate Majority Defendants’ (and other parties’) concerns about ‘respecting the cores of prior districts,’ insisting such claims are merely ‘pretextual arguments for protecting incumbents,’ they wrote in their letter. “As a threshold matter, incumbency protection is a traditional redistricting principle, as Professor Persily himself has previously recognized.”

The letter further argued against placing incumbents politicians in the same districts if at all possible.

“[A]voiding incumbency pairings actually enhances the reality and appearance of judicial impartiality,” they wrote, again contending protecting sitting Representatives should be more highly prioritized in the process.

Continue reading “Senate GOP Objection: Court Map ‘Needlessly Violates New York’s Traditional Redistricting Principles’”