Cuomo Mocks Goo-Goos Redistricting ‘Tirades’

andrewcuomo Cuomo Mocks Goo Goos Redistricting TiradesAndrew Cuomo appeared on Fred Dicker’s radio show this morning and had some gentle teasing for the good government groups that have been decrying this year’s redistricting process.

“What people forget when they get all hyped up about it–the legislature has the legal authority to draw the lines. It is in the Constitution. The good government groups forget that when they do their tirade about how terrible the lines are,” Mr. Cuomo said over the audible snorts of Mr. Dicker. “Constitutionally the legislature has the right to do it.”

After noting that the matter will likely go to court to see if the lines that the legislature ends up drawing are legal, Mr. Cuomo laid out his plan to reform the whole process by making nonpartisan redistricting the law of the land. He added that the lines as currently drawn are “hyper-political and offensive” and that he would veto them.

It is worth noting here that a Constitutional amendment won’t solve all of the redistricting process. An amendment would have to pass the legislature twice, and could easily be amended by the time it went into effect for the 2010 round of redistricting.  Thus, some good-government types have been in the awkward position of opposing Mr. Cuomo’s plan to permanently deal with the problem, since they view it as a temporary, reversible fix.

Mr. Cuomo however said that if they don’t get a Constitutional amendment, this problem will keep occurring.

“Many of our friends nowadays have been around a short time. I remember going through this during the Pataki years, I remember it during the Mario Cuomo years.  This will happen again in ten years. We just played the video tape at one point.I would like to see real reform.”

 

 

 

 

 

2 thoughts on “Cuomo Mocks Goo-Goos Redistricting ‘Tirades’

  1. As usual, the Governor is lying.  He knows full well the Constitution requires legislative APPROVAL of a redistricting plan.  The legislature has already delegated their authority to LATFOR, they could easily delegate to an independent commission (as many other states do), and then resolve whether or not to pass the plan from the independent commission.

    He’s positioning to cut the deal with Silver and Skelos, and is maneuvering now to backslide on his fake pledge from two years ago.  The question is whether the goo-goos decide to go along with his flip-flop.

  2. “‘What people forget when they get all hyped up about it–the legislature
    has the legal authority to draw the lines. It is in the Constitution.
    The good government groups forget that when they do their tirade about
    how terrible the lines are,’ Mr. Cuomo said…”

    No, I don’t think the good government groups have forgotten that. Of course the legislature has the legal authority to draw the lines. But that doesn’t mean that the lines that they draw can’t be justifiably criticized as absurd and as more in the interests of the political parties and their incumbents than in the interests of the public at large.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s