Bill Thompson Redux: Can The ’09 Runner-Up Win The Second Time Around?

thompson 2009 Bill Thompson Redux: Can The 09 Runner Up Win The Second Time Around?On Election Night 2009, Bill Thompson was in his suite at The Hilton and was one of the few people in New York who thought he was about to become the city’s next mayor. Polls from even the week before had him down by as much as 18 points to Mike Bloomberg, and the mayor’s $100 million plus campaign operation had been blitzing the city. They bragged about turnout operation that would be “the most expansive and effective this city has ever seen.” Early in the evening, the networks and the newspapers declared Mr. Bloomberg the winner. Senior Democrats called Mr. Thompson in his suite to offer congratulations, and condolences.

Mr. Thompson told them to wait. Their own returns showed them trailing, but not by that much. “We may have this,” he told aides. The networks reversed themselves; suddenly the race was too close to call. Downstairs in the ballroom, what was thought to be an early evening was turning to disbelief as Thompson aides cursed the city’s Democratic political class—and even President Obama—for lending him only the most perfunctory support because they presumed he was destined for defeat.

As Mr. Bloomberg ultimately inched ahead, the Hilton ballroom morphed into a raucous victory party for the loser. Norman Seabrook, a fiery union head, went on live TV and blasted those “that were supposed to be supportive, that considered themselves Democrats”as “full of shit.” Mr. Thompson’s supporters, mostly Black and Latino lawmakers, crowded onto the stage, and crowed.

When the time came for Mr. Thompson to address the swelling crowd, he said, “The work we started during this campaign doesn’t end tonight. In fact, it’s just beginning.”

And indeed, only a couple of months after the race, Mr. Thompson made one of the most unexpected moves a city politician has made in a long time: he announced that he was running for mayor again, and would be on the ballot four years hence.

And then, just as quickly, Mr. Thompson disappeared.

Sure, he would pop up at occasional political rally or as the head of a Gov. Andrew Cuomo-appointed commission, but anyone who thought Mr. Thompson would spend the next four years as mayor-in-exile, making the Democratic case against Mayor Bloomberg, was sorely disappointed. In March he told The Observer that he expected to make a campaign announcement “in the next day or two.” For months afterwards, nothing. This led to inevitable questions, that despite his ultra-early announcement, Mr. Thompson would in the end take a pass.

“I think it worked to some people’s advantage to say, ‘He’s not going to run.’ Because if I am running it makes it harder for people to say, here is their path,” Mr. Thompson said last week. “I don’t know that you have to convince people. I am out, I am around at events. I am going to be a presence again.”

Due to his absence, Mr. Thompson has been able to avoid most of the battles that have roiled the city’s political class over the last couple of years. In an interview he struck a far-more centrist tone than many of his fellow 2013 candidates. He has genuinely nice things to say about NYPD chief Ray Kelly. He doesn’t favor the most recent living wage bill that was before the City Council. He is non-committal on the paid sick leave bill. He is against a city “millionaire’s tax.”

But despite saying that he is not running against Mike Bloomberg, Mr. Thompson these days sounds very much like someone running against Mike Bloomberg. He blasted the administration for trying to turn the city into a “luxury product,” for overly onerous regulations and fines that hurt small businesses, and for eight “wasted years” of education reforms.

Mr. Thompson’s Bloomberg-bashing isn’t about sour grapes. Mr. Bloomberg may not be on the ballot next time around, but Christine Quinn, who appears to base her campaign as a continuation of the current regime, will be. And thanks to her impressive fundraising haul and good early polling numbers, Ms. Quinn has emerged as the frontrunner. But as Thompson advisors see it, he is the frontrunner, and the only question is whether Ms. Quinn can prevent him from securing the 40 percent of the vote needed to avoid a run-off.

They note that in a Democratic primary, nearly half of the vote will be African-American or Hispanic. And although Bill de Blasio, whose wife is African-American and who is a popular figure among many minority-dominated labor unions, and John Liu, who cobbled together a coalition of blacks, Hispanics and Asians in his own comptroller’s race, can each lay claim to a portion of that electorate, Mr. Thompson got over 75 percent of the African-American vote in his three citywide runs, and typically got over half of the Hispanic votes as well.

“And this is from a guy who has never run as just a black candidate,” said Eddy Castell, one of Mr. Thompson’s advisors. “The question is can he get to 40 percent and not be in a run-off. He is the only guy who walks in with 25-30 percent of the Democratic vote in his pocket.”

Demographics aside, Mr. Thompson’s strongest claim to early front-runner status is that surprising near-victory in 2009. But the credit for that shocking near-upset is in dispute. Bloomberg campaign advisers say that Mr. Thompson is profoundly misinterpreting the results if he thinks his campaign was the reason behind the close victory. The 50 percent of the vote that Mr. Bloomberg received, they said, was pretty close to his ceiling. Term limits had angered too many voters, as had 8 years of administration polices and edicts, tickets and fines. The Obama wave in 2008 had swelled even further the number of registered Democrats in a town where they already outnumber Republicans five-to-one.

One thought on “Bill Thompson Redux: Can The ’09 Runner-Up Win The Second Time Around?

  1. Great journalism! (duh) You missed the stealth and steady Scott Stringer. . .He has raised over 2 million dollars and has been playing Zelig all over the City (outer boroughs included).  Bill Thompson doesn’t have two nickels to rub together and is out of favor in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens Democratic circles.  He will NEVER get the Staten Island vote (due to his snub of the “Forgotten Borough” in the last election) and Bronx is up for grabs.

    Stringer has poked his head into creating more available fresh produce for inner city neighborhoods…spoke out against unwarranted police Stop and Frisks…dug into the Downtown Mosque debate (citing Freedom of Worship), while also supporting a respectful 9-11 Memorial. . . The guys is a neighborhood guy with the added plus of growing up in Manhattan.

    Watch out Thompson! (and Liu, DeBlasio, and Quinn!)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s